223 Comments

Atavistic Shibboleths

BAhq-STCYAExKO7-480x658
I’m out of step again. If supporting Arsenal was a dance I’d be treading on every toe in the room. It’s OK don’t feel sorry for me, I’m quite used to it. When we were playing in hugely entertaining games but coming out with honours shared in multi scoring draws or losing by the odd goal or as a result of hugely prejudicial refereeing decisions I often found myself in a minority of one. I stood like the little boy still waving his flag after the procession had passed saying to nobody “Wasn’t that a gay parade, colourful and exciting?” as everyone else in the street marched grumbling back into their houses angry, cheated, feeling the costumes were less flamboyant than in previous years, the music a little discordant, the majorettes skirts less high than they liked and the baton twirls not as extravagant as they might have been.

My final contribution, I genuinely believed it to be forever, to the world of Arsenal blogging was to ask, almost a year ago now and following a three three draw with Fulham, whether there was any other single person out there who could agree that the match had been entertaining and good to watch. Nobody could. I said that in that event I would keep my counsel. That I did until George and Adi inflated the enormous bouncy castle that is Positively Arsenal and enquired as to whether or not I might like to jump on and try a few somersaults. The rest is, to polish a very tired and already shining cliché, history. Or at least so I had assumed. Increasingly though I’m finding myself once more moving into a position of isolation. Remarks passed are missing my bulls eye by a fraction and the popular note is not, to my ear at least, always quite true.

Before you begin to berate me for a curmudgeonly, or as my Caledonian comrades would have it, a carnaptious outlook during this time of celebration and general rejoicing among the Arsenal cognoscenti, stay your sword hand, I beg, keep your powder dry, and hear me out. I am not miserable, nor am I deliberately dour simply in a spirit of perverse contradiction. I have been accused of such contrary instincts often enough in the past and so I must presume that there could be some truth in the accusation, one is put in mind of the old clench about a stopped clock being correct at least twice a day. However on this occasion I am certain I can defend my position against such a prosecution case.

In the first instance I believe I may meet with a favourable reception. I am hugely antagonised by the refusal of the media, exemplified by the apparatchiks at ЅҠЧ ЅРѺЯТЅ on Tuesday evening, to give simple unvarnished credit where it is manifestly due. Arsenal did not in fact play the most outstanding, beautiful efficient and yet inventive football imaginable. Instead Napoli were a disappointment. Napoli were poor. Napoli were sure to come out and show more in the second half. The script cannot be changed, Arsène cannot be given credit for what he has been building at the Emirates all these years because then the real power in football would have to admit they’d been wrong and force a different editorial line from the wooden lips of their ventriloqual dolls. I’m sure we were all as annoyed by the commentators search for excuses to prop up their tired arguments. Thank goodness for the French TV coverage I eventually secured. Where I differ from the rest of you perhaps is my reaction to the media circus where there is evidence or at least the suggestion of a change of heart. People are rejoicing that the papers are beginning to recognise that we are resurgent, that we have awoken and the bad or lean times are behind us. I hear folk talking with glee how this negative blog or that radio show are saying that from the depths of despair when we lost to Villa and inspired by our new Deutsche Wunderkind Arsenal are suddenly a different team. And this is one of things that really pisses me off.

The media are not saying “We got it wrong, we’re sorry for all the scurrilous nonsense we’ve talked about the great Monsieur Wenger and his long term plan” of course they aren’t and they never will. What they are actually saying is Arsenal were shit until Arsène finally caved in and spent some fackin’ money – just like they’d always told him to. I can’t celebrate that. I can’t celebrate when they propagate the nonsense that Mesut Özil inspired us to victory over Napoli as I heard this morning or that he was ‘at the heart of everything good about Arsenal” as I read. Apart from the fact that by any sensible measure no one stood out in what was the consummate team performance (except possibly Aaron Ramsey who was the best man on the pitch in the first half and by quite a long way) the comments are at best lazy –

Arsenal spend a lot of money on a player ergo he must be the best player at the club

or self serving –

we always said Arsenal would never do anything until they spent some fackin’ money so now we will ignore the facts and thus prove ourselves correct.

So don’t expect me to cheer when these lying scumbags appear to be blowing smoke up our kilts. They will turn on us at the first bad result and won’t ever give credit for the fact that this team was already in the midst of an incredible run, which has continued and to which Özil is merely one contributing factor. The real story is the platform Arsène has assembled upon which the likes of Mesut can strut their stuff.

Another area where I find myself out of step with many of my friends is this mood of vindication, this feeling that the results have proved us to be right and yar boo sucks to anyone who doubted our positive support in the past. I’m reading Roy Jenkins huge and hugely enjoyable biography of Churchill at the moment and it has given me pause on this subject on more than one occasion. The old warhorse was very fond of saying “In war, resolution; in defeat, defiance; in victory, magnanimity” and a little bit of that magnanimity wouldn’t go amiss right now. Apart from anything else I don’t think it is the results or current form that proves us to have been right for standing defiant by the manager in recent times. Churchill was furious at Chamberlain’s betrayal of Czechoslovakia in 1938 and ’39 and made many dire predictions about the calamitous outcome of a continued policy of appeasement. My argument is he wasn’t proven right by the carnage that ensued in the following years, he was right to be appalled at the perfidious treachery shown by the Western allies to the Czech people regardless of the outcome. Even if Hitler had stopped there and Europe had enjoyed decades of peaceful prosperity it wouldn’t alter the fact that allowing the fascist annexation of another country would have been wrong. Full stop. Wrong because it was wrong by any moral measurement not wrong because of the way things turned out. In our perhaps less cataclysmic area of concern, we would have been right to support our manager and players irrespective of the results they went on to achieve. We are supporters and we could clearly see what Arsène was trying to achieve and how he was going about it. It was right and proper to support him in that quest. If we’d lost a few more games this season than we have that position would still have remained the correct one. We supported him simply because it was the right thing to do and this good run of results is not relevant. ‘I told you so’ has no place for me.

forgive

I know what you’re thinking – lighten up Stew and let us have our moment for goodness sake. Fine go ahead I don’t blame you and I too am revelling in the football and the results. I’m happy for players like Aaron and Tomas after their personal tribulations and I’m delighted for Arsène to be where he deserves to be, I am a little bit in love with Per Mertesacker and if it means the team is winning I’m content to be proven right. I just don’t buy the media line and don’t think it healthy for anyone else so to do, oh and I prefer magnanimity to gloating any day of the week. The former is sun kissed and virtuous residing upon lofty moral high ground, the latter lives in a squalid detritus choked gutter of self regard. Having said all that I’m not immune to the instinct to poke out my tongue at my detractors. To that end I have one delicious quotation to share with you from Jenkins’ weighty tome. Churchill was adept at putting people in their place with a pithy or elegantly turned phrase, in fact this remains one of the things for which he is most famous. However he was, unsurprisingly perhaps, occasionally on the receiving end of some pretty stiff stuff. When I consider some of the awful accusations levelled at us Positivistas, that we were living in the past, that events had left us behind and we were clinging to the promise of false hope based on Arsène’s achievements from a sadly bygone age, the words of the Marquess of Linlithgow from a written exchange with WSC in 1932 spring instantly to mind. “Forgive me then if I say that it is not, it seems to me, so much I who am mouthing the bland platitudes of an age that has passed away … but rather you who are hanging hairy from a branch while you splutter the atavistic shibboleths destined by some to retreat into the forgotten past”.

Now that is a put down.

About steww

Unknown's avatar
bass guitar, making mistakes, buggering on regardless.

Comment navigation

Newer Comments →

223 comments on “Atavistic Shibboleths

  1. Boo!
    Foy you fuckwit.

    Like

  2. Double damn it.

    Like

  3. Dear! Sunderland did drop off and Altidore hasn’t been good enough to provide threat to hold up the ball. Hope they can get a set piece or something to equalize but they look a little sluggish and out of ideas right now.

    Like

  4. DC, I think WBA are very good and have certainly played us tough the last several encounters. At home and after playing MU off the pitch, I think they’ll feel, hopefully, that they really have to attack at home, so we might have a good chance to play the way we did v. Napoli. Should be a really good game, I think!

    Like

  5. Now that I’ve said this they could come out to park the bus and take a negative frustrating approach for a dull and tense match!!

    Like

  6. So United had to depend on an 18 year old to bail them out of an embarrassing defeat against the worst team in the league Onto the title I am sure will be the cry of the media and their plastic supporters.
    Methinks it is a little bit too early to either write them off or to conclude they have overcome their weaknesses.
    Yes, I know it is not a bold, bullish opinion as I expect them to be fighting for a top-4 position next May. Anything less and I would be very surprised.

    Like

  7. So onto the Hawthorns tomorrow. As good as we have been those anxious butterflies are fluttering in my tummy. In my head I trust the team but my heart dreads uncertainty and complacency . Very comforting is this piece at Untold Arsenal explaining “What’s so different at Arsenal that has led to this improvement?” at http://tinyurl.com/onrvuuj

    Like

  8. For fucks sake,
    Just seeing replays of the city peno – a rip off.
    Ashley Young woud be embarrassed by the dive.

    Like

  9. Shoot. I was hoping for at least one good result. Everton let me down.
    No matter. We shall take care of bussiness tomorrow.

    Like

  10. Shoot. I was hoping for at least one good result. Everton let me down.
    No matter. We shall take care of bussiness tomorrow.
    COYG

    Like

  11. gervinho is doing the damage in italy. happy for him.

    Like

  12. The Mancs scraped by Sunderland. Altidore is piss poor, really.

    The blue Mancs cheated past Everton. Also, Martinez got his subs wrong. I didn’t understand how Gibson came in for Lukaku when they needed a goal.

    There was no way Liverpool were going to lose against such a poor Crystal Palace.

    Like

  13. Shotta
    Thanks for the link to untold. Myths need to be busted.
    Poznan did some excellent work on the same subject:

    it’s Not The Defense, Stoopid.

    Like

  14. Gains Liverpool didn’t have a midfield today.
    Neither did Manure.

    Arsenal have the two best midfield quartets in England, if not Europe.

    Like

  15. Ramsey Flamini Arteta Ozil

    Jack Rosicky Ox Santi

    And Diaby & Frimmy!

    Like

  16. You could take any of the first eight out and put Diaby in and it would be no weaker

    Like

  17. Do you know that Arsene said Diaby was “the most complete midfield player I have ever seen”
    That’s some accolade.

    Like

  18. Deschamps said much the same PG.
    The fact that he could be back in November or December is tantalising.

    he could be like an new sig………

    Where’s my coat?

    Like

  19. The prospect of Diaby up against Yaya and Ramires is so much to hope for.

    The kit man is going to have to make sure he has stitched in massive sized pockets in Diaby’s shorts.
    Come on Abu, you’re nearly back!

    Like

  20. So Robin without a supply is fairly useless?

    Like

  21. DC, Lucas was out due to card accumulation so they played the £16m rated Jordan Henderson in his stead.

    Like

  22. Adebayor was a mere shadow of himself when he didn’t have Rosicky, Cesc and Hleb feeding him passes.

    Like

  23. GAINS
    it the system you know. Many ARSENAL players failed to reach the heights they achieved with the GUNNERS when they moved away prematurely. The majority I would venture.
    adebywhore has become a side note. A gypsy millionaire vagabond.
    Big game today . Must reclaim top spot from pool to demoralize them all. I think MONREAL will fill in for GIBBS. TOMAS to get the call to recreate the magic of last year. COYG…
    UP WITH THEM GUNNNNNSSSSS!!!!!!!!

    Like

Comment navigation

Newer Comments →

Comments are closed.